8B Consent 2007 1001 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

Nevertheless, based on Mr. Rogala's objection to the Landmark status, recordation with the Alameda County Recorder's office was placed on hold. Mr. Bohne stated he has no research documentation or arborist information available to explain why the redwood trees were deemed to be historically significant in 1974. Mr. Mike Rogala, 651 Juana Avenue, addressed the Commission, describing the numerous problems he continues to have with his redwood trees. He explained the hazards, nuisances and economic burdens associated with being responsible for the trees. Mr. Rogala said he likes trees, but tall redwood trees are problematic and dangerous, especially during windstorms. Today a tree service company contracted by PG&E came to remove a branch because a neighbor complained it had fallen on a power line. Mr. Rogala stated he wants to be able to make decisions about maintaining his trees without being constrained by a Landmark status. He consulted with a certified arborist who estimated the age of the trees to be 50 or 60, and not more than 70, years old. Mr. Rogala believes the historic status is not appropriate. Chair Kaplan told Mr. Rogala he has done a thorough job of presenting his case and explaining the problems with his trees. Commissioner Symons said as a homeowner, Mr. Rogala should be allowed to make decisions about the maintenance and safety of his property. The redwood trees do not fit the criteria of Landmark status. Commissioner D. Reed said if the trees were historically significant this situation would be different. But there doesn't seem to be any evidence available to support historic ' significance of the trees. Commissioner Reicker said Mr. Rogala has made a persuasive case regarding the safety and economic issues associated with his trees, and he demonstrated due diligence by consulting a tree expert. Commissioner Reicker said Mr. Rogala should be allowed to manage his property as he sees fit. It was MSC (Symons/Lum) to approve Mr. Rogala's request to rescind the Landmark status of the redwood trees on his property at 651 Juana Avenue. ACTIVITY REPORTS: A. Library Usage--Noted. B. Circulation-Mr. Bohne noted circulation figures increased this year. Our Sunday circulation has started very well. CORRESPONDENCE: A. State Library LSTA Grant Award, 12-6-06: Commissioners Lum and Reicker asked for an explanation of the LSTA Grant Award. Mr. Bohne said the Federal government used to administer grant funds directly to libraries. Now it's the -2-