Minutes 1998 0302 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

.` Minutes - City of San Leandro City Council Meeting March 2, 1998 Page - 11 - The City Attorney explained what is before the Council this evening is the issue of when this matter gets placed on the ballot - the issue of the gun tax itself was debated in 1996, and the Council decided at that time it would have to be passed by the electorate to become effective. He concluded by stating it is his opinion that this ordinance would withstand legal scrutiny - in his judgment the City would prevail. Council Member Galvan asked where the attorneys are that stated during the first process they would defend the City pro bono. He feels this situation is different from those in the past, in that the party affected is not in agreement with the ordinance. Vice Mayor Loeffler stated this is a defining issue for the Council. His posture has not changed on the issue. He feels the City cannot be the host of the largest, gun-sales business and feel it does not impact the communities around us. He commented on the cost of gun violence in our society and stressed the increasing threat to the young people in our community. He added that he spent 20 years in the military, and he has an enormous respect for guns, but feels it is appropriate to reduce opportunities for guns to be used. He agreed this tax is punitive. He also agreed the tobacco and liquor tax is punitive, as they should be. He feels the Council should let the people make the decision regarding the gun tax. Council Member Young commented that, if she thought a gun tax would save lives, she would have voted "Yes" in 1996. She feels it will not save lives. This tax will not generate enough money to make a difference. If this measure passes, she feels the monies should be used to better the community. She clarified that tobacco and alcohol taxes are Federal taxes. She feels the gun tax will pass if you put it on the ballot and that the people may choose it over the other two taxes proposed, putting them in jeopardy. She suggested, perhaps there should be a license on the sale of bullets. Council Member Lothrop agreed with Vice Mayor Loeffler. She stated the gun store on East 14th Street sells the largest amount of weapons west of the Mississippi. Council Member Galvan commented that the victims of gun violence should be the ones who benefit from this tax - why can't that be done? Mayor Corbett commented that the Business License Fee funds are not earmarked for Police Officers in particular. The Council does have control of the budget and, therefore, can budget funds to benefit victims, should they wish to do so. The issue before this Council tonight i s whether or not to place thi s matter on the June 2, 1998, ballot. She feels, if the Council does not place it on the ballot, the Council takes away the people's choice in the matter. She added that she believes this tax can help save lives and keep guns off the street. Council can assist victims through the budget process. She further commented on the importance of keeping our community out of harm's way. She concluded by stating discussions were held with Mr. Cucchiara regarding the type of guns the Council was concerned about and that this tax should be levied upon.