10B Action 2012 0702 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

2. Patients and Cardholders A dispensary obviously is not a patient or cardholder. A "qualified patient" is an individual with a physician's recommendation that indicates marijuana will benefit the treatment of a qualifying illness. (Cal. H &S Code secs. 11362.5(b)(1)(A) and 11362.7(f).) Qualified illnesses include cancer, anorexia, AIDS, chronic pain, spasticity, glaucoma, arthritis, migraine, or any other illness for which marijuana provides relief 7 A physician's recommendation that indicates medical marijuana will benefit the treatment of an illness is required before a person can claim to be a medical marijuana patient. Accordingly, such proof is also necessary before a medical marijuana affirmative defense can be claimed. A "person with an identification card" means an individual who is a qualified patient who has applied for and received a valid identification card issued by the State Department of Health Services. (Cal. H &S Code secs. 11362.7(c) and 11362.7(g).) 3. Primary Caregivers The only person or entity authorized to receive compensation for services provided to patients and cardholders is a primary caregiver. (Cal. H &S Code sec. 11362.77(c).) However, nothing in the law authorizes any individual or group to cultivate or distribute marijuana for profit. (Cal. H &S Code sec. 11362.765(a).) It is important to note that it is almost impossible for a storefront marijuana business to gain true primary caregiver status. Businesses that call themselves "cooperatives," but function like storefront dispensaries, suffer this same fate. In People v. Mower, the court was very clear that the defendant had to prove he was a primary caregiver in order to raise the medical marijuana affirmative defense. Mr. Mower was prosecuted for supplying two people with marijuana. 18 He claimed he was their primary caregiver under the medical marijuana statutes. This claim required him to prove he "consistently had assumed responsibility for either one's housing, health, or safety" before he could assert the defense. (Emphasis added.) The key to being a primary caregiver is not simply that marijuana is provided for a patient's health; the responsibility for the health must be consistent; it must be independent of merely providing marijuana for a qualified person; and such a primary caregiver - patient relationship must begin before or contemporaneously with the time of assumption of responsibility for assisting the individual with marijuana. (People v. Mentch (2008) 45 Cal.4th 274, 283.) Any relationship a storefront marijuana business has with a patient is much more likely to be transitory than consistent, and to be wholly lacking in providing for a patient's health needs beyond just supplying him or her with marijuana. A "primary caregiver" is an individual or facility that has "consistently assumed responsibility for the housing, health, or safety of a patient" overtime. (Cal. H &S Code sec. 11362.5(e).) "Consistency" is the key to meeting this definition. A patient can elect to patronize any dispensary that he or she chooses. The patient can visit different dispensaries on a single day or any subsequent day. The statutory definition includes some clinics, health care facilities, residential care facilities, and hospices. But, in light of the holding in People v. Mentch, supra, to qualify as a primary caregiver, more aid to a person's health must occur beyond merely dispensing marijuana to a given customer. Additionally, if more than one patient designates the same person as the primary caregiver, all individuals must reside in the same city or county. And, in most circumstances the primary caregiver must be at least 18 years of age. © 2009 California Police Chiefs Assn. 4 All Rights Reserved