3C Presentation 2014 0519 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home

File Number: 14-190 to trees on private property). For trees on private property, staff provided the following options : No changes to current policies; development of regulations that only pertain to properties zoned for commercial, industrial, or multi-family uses (specifically exclude single-family properties from any regulation); develop standards related to development sites; and develop a method to define and protect significant trees with historic, heritage, or landmark value. The staff report noted that for an ordinance to be successful , it must have the support of the community. While most residents recognize the value of trees to the community, the majority of community input in 1999 did not support a tree preservation ordinance that would regulate tree removal on single-family lots. Thus, staff recommended that the City not proceed with developing a tree ordinance governing single-family lots. Current Policy Title 12, Chapter 8 of the Administrative Code applies specifically to City street trees (trees in the public right-of-way), the planting thereof, removal, trimming, other maintenance, and administrative authority. With the exception of trees that were required plantings as part of a project undergoing zoning/planning approval (and which are covered as part of the project’s mitigation measures or conditions of approval) there are no City policies that regulate the planting or removal of trees on private property, regardless of zoning. Analysis and Policy Proposal Chapter 7 of the 2002 General Plan, entitled ‘Historic Preservation and Community Design’ notes the major role that landscaping (both in the public right-of-way and on private property) plays in how San Leandro looks and feels. This Chapter 7 of the City’s General Plan provides that, “Ultimately, a greener and more attractive City can provide economic and property value benefits as well as ecological and aesthetic benefits.” General Plan Policy 44.03 provides as follows: “…Encourage the preservation and proper care of mature trees throughout the City, particularly those which may have historic importance or contribute substantially to neighborhood character.” Action 44.03-A: Tree Preservation speaks to providing incentives for property owners to maintain significant trees and reduce the burden of maintenance. Redwood trees at Juana / Bancroft, and 647 and 651 Juana are noted as Historic Landscape Elements in the 2002 General Plan; they are identified on the City’s Local Register of Historic Significance, and thus they are protected by Ordinance 74-12. The attached draft ordinance borrows primarily from the cities of Pleasanton and Walnut Creek, with the intent to be mid-range in regulating trees on private property. The attached Exhibit 1 is a matrix of tree ordinance information from the websites of other Alameda County cities. Please note when looking at the numbers that some cities measure using diameter, while others use circumference. The circumference of a tree is measured at Pi (3.14) x diameter. Also, the height at which the measurement is taken varies from three feet above grade to four feet, six inches. When not specified, typical measurements are taken at breast height (hence the common terms CBH, Circumference at Breast Height and DBH, Diameter at Breast Height). For those cities that do regulate on private property (as shown in Exhibit 1), the attached Exhibit 2 is a simplified comparison chart. The axis on the left represents the regulated Page 2 City of San Leandro Printed on 5/13/2014