Laserfiche WebLink
4. Alternatives <br />4.4 Technical and Regulatory Opportunities and <br />Constraints <br />This section summarizes the permitting and regulatory authorization opportunities and constraints <br />related to the three alternatives currently proposed for the San Leandro Harbor Basin project. The <br />structure of this section includes a description of each alternative and its permitting requirements, <br />permitting constraints for each alternative and a ranking of each alternative based on permitting <br />constraints only. <br />Permitting Requirements for All Alternatives <br />Implementing any of the three alternatives for the San Leandro Harbor Basin would require some <br />level of regulatory permitting. Table 4-4 lists the permits required, issuing resource agency, and the <br />specific alternative details that would require permits. The details on the constraints are provided <br />below. <br />TABLE 4-4 <br />AGENCIES AND REQUIRED AUTHORIZATIONS <br />USACE <br />BCDC <br />RWQCB <br />CDFG <br />NMFS <br />USFWS <br />No Action Alternative <br />No construction <br />No construction <br />No construction <br />No construction <br />No construction <br />No construction <br />Marina Part Alternative <br />404 and 10: <br />Coastal <br />401 Water <br />2081 or 2080.1: <br />Biological <br />Biological <br />Placement of fill <br />Development <br />Quality <br />During <br />Opinion. During <br />Opinion: During <br />for high marsh <br />Permit: <br />Certification: <br />construction for <br />construction for <br />construction for <br />and riprap. <br />Backfilling, pier <br />Placement of fill <br />protection of <br />protection of <br />protection of <br />Removal of <br />removal, <br />for high marsh <br />state listed <br />federal listed fish <br />Federal listed <br />piers/pilings <br />relocation of <br />and riprap. <br />species <br />terrestrial <br />Marina office, <br />Removal of <br />species and fish <br />and fill related to <br />piers/pilings <br />high marsh <br />creation <br />Aquatic Park Alternative <br />404 and 10: <br />Coastal <br />401 Water <br />2081 or 2080.1: <br />Biological <br />Biological <br />Placement of fill <br />Development <br />Quality <br />During <br />Opinion. During <br />Opinion: During <br />for high marsh <br />Permit: <br />Certification: <br />construction for <br />construction for <br />construction for <br />and riprap. <br />Backfilling, pier <br />Placement of fill <br />protection of <br />protection of <br />protection of <br />Removal of <br />removal, and fill <br />for high marsh <br />state listed <br />federal listed fish <br />Federal listed <br />piers/pilings <br />related to high <br />and riprap. <br />species <br />terrestrial <br />marsh creation <br />Removal of <br />species and fish <br />piers/piling <br />Nature Park Alternative <br />404 and 10: <br />Coastal <br />401 Water <br />2081 or 2080.1: <br />Biological <br />Biological <br />Placement of fill <br />Development <br />Quality <br />During <br />Opinion. During <br />Opinion: During <br />for high marsh <br />Permit: <br />Certification: <br />construction for <br />construction for <br />construction for <br />and riprap. <br />Backfilling, pier <br />Placement of fill <br />protection of <br />protection of <br />protection of <br />Removal of <br />removal, and fill <br />for high marsh <br />state listed <br />federal listed fish <br />Federal listed <br />piers/pilings, if <br />related to high <br />and riprap. <br />species <br />terrestrial <br />applicable <br />marsh creation <br />Removal of <br />species and fish <br />piers/piling <br />San Leandro Marina Harbor Basin 4-14 ESA / 210461 <br />Alternatives Study March 2011 <br />